Archives

Children’s Book Review: *Slob* by Ellen Potter

  • Slob by Ellen Potter
  • Reading level: Ages 9-12
  • Hardcover: 199 pages
  • Publisher: Philomel (May 14, 2009)
  • ISBN-13: 978-0399247057
  • Back of the book blurb:  Twelve-year-old Owen Birnbaum is the fattest kid in school.  But he’s also a genius who invents cool contraptions— like a TV that shows the past.  Something happened two years ago that he needs to see.  But genius or not, there is much Owen can’t outthink.  Like his gym coach, who’s on a mission to humiliate him.  Or the way his Oreos keep disappearing from his lunch.  He’s sure that if he can only get the TV to work, things will start to make sense.  But it will take a revelation for Owen, not science, to see the answer’s not in the past, but the present.  That no matter how large he is on the outside, he doesn’t have to feel small on the inside.

    She is Too Fond of Books’ review:  Welcome to the world of Owen Birnbaum!  Owen, his sister (Jeremy), and all the school-age characters in Slob are written as realistic and complex adolescents.  To them, facing the day-to-day challenges of pre-teens can sometimes appear as daunting as maintaining world peace, or ending hunger.  And then there are the out-of-the-ordinary circumstances faced by Owen, which would be a struggle for most adults.

    Owen is fat.  Fat and brilliant.  He is fiercly protective of 11-year-old Jeremy, and, although not part of an “in crowd,” he does have a close friend in school.  Because of his weight gain, Owen has been subject to  verbal bullying.  Instead of standing up to the bullies and defending himself, he imagines himself as useless as a boulder:

    I stood there for a minute feeling especially fat.  I mean, I always feel fat, but sometimes I feel like a boulder … and I just stand there, letting it happen, because I’m a boulder and that’s what boulders do.

    Slob is especially engaging because it is told in the first person.  Emotions and observations are told at the level of a 12-year-old (albeit a very mature and intelligent 12-year-old).  I was immediately brought back as an observer in my own late elementary and early middle school days, witnessing the humiliation of gym class through Owen’s eyes.

    I’ll share another excerpt that struck me.  Owen is in his closet going through a bag of clothes he wore two years ago, before his weight gain.  He questions who he is, and who he has become, as he faces the memories stirred up by the clothes.  I also like the mention of the Yankees/Red Sox rivalry, as it mirrors our own family’s alliances:

     … I held them up, one by one.  Had my body once fit into these things?  It was almost unimaginable.  I felt like I must have been a totally different person.  Like I had died and been reborn as someone else.  I remembered things I had forgotten about too, the way you do when you look at old photographs.  I could remember that I had worn one particular shirt on our trip to Ottawa, or how my NY Yankees shirt always made my parents squabble about the baseball teams – my mother was from Boston.

    My 11-year-old son really enjoyed Slob, telling me “I know kids who’ve had things like that happen to them … but not as bad!”  When he let me have a turn with the book, I was immediately taken with Owen, and quite curious to see if he would transform from a boulder to a rolling stone.  Slob, with its many layered messages and subtle lessons will be read and re-read by my children.  Highly recommended for boys and girls; I’ve already passed the title along to my son’s fifth grade teacher, and to my niece, who teaches fourth grade.

    Ellen Potter is also the author of the Olivia Kidney series and Pish Posh.  Slob has just been award the Junior Library Guild Spring 2009 selection.

    20 comments to Children’s Book Review: *Slob* by Ellen Potter

    • I love this book, too. I thought Owen and Jeremy were great!

    • These are the kids that will develop the next Apple company, so I’m sure they will have the last laugh! Great review, and its good to know more about this book. It would be the type of book that our principal would pull off the shelves of our Book Fair, just by the title. Now I can defend it!

    • One of the great things about children’s books (especially for this age group) is that they can teach empathy. I will definitely be picking this book up for my kids to read as they get older. I have this huge fear of my kids growing up without empathy towards other people and their problems. Thanks for the review and bringing this one to my attention!

    • kay

      Wow, that looks like a great and original read! Seems like it’s well written, too. I’m definitely adding it to me TBR list!

    • Kathy – I think it will be for my son like a lot of Judy Blume books were for me at that age – truthful and open about a lot of things that people don’t readily talk about.

      Sandy – Yes, I hope you and your kids read it … defend away!!

      Michele – my son marches to the beat of his own drummer, more arty than sporty, so I was glad to see Owen as such a strong character in his own right.

      Kay – Let me know what you think after you read it … I think you’ll like SLOB!

    • This looks like such a good read. I’ll definitely have to add it to my list.

    • Awesome review! I’ve read other good reviews of this book as well and have put this book on the reading list for the summer. Thanks!

    • Belle – I haven’t read a mid-grade book to myself for a while (only as read-alouds with the kids). really, really like SLOB!

      zibilee – I don’t think you can go wrong with this as a pick!

    • My little brother always had weight issues and still does though it’s more under control now. If he was more of a reader I know he would have liked this.

    • Max

      This is a great book, one of the best i have ever read, i’m going through school right now and i see so much of this, it’s easy to connect to it.

    • LadyTink – I enjoyed reading it as much as my kids did!

      Max – I’m glad to hear you’re connecting with Owen, Jeremy, and the other kids. Have you read other books by Ellen Potter?

    • Also really enjoyed SLOB-Thanks for the review.

    • megan

      i loved tis book, i am a teenager, and i recently read it for a book project! i love this book so mnuch, and i recomend it to all of the younger adults!

    • makayla

      i really like this book so much that i am doing a book report on it at school.

    • cam

      i love this book it makes me lol the best book ever written

    • i am with cam on this one

    • Navara

      Reading it for 6th grade book club! Love it!

    • Sydney Roby

      I am reading this book for a 6th grade book report.

    • James Mider

      this book is dum

    • kathy

      this book can suck it… it is making fun of fat people and that is not cool….do you think that it is a good book becasue it makes fun of people that are geeks who are nt athletic and are “the fattest kid in school”

    Leave a Reply

     

     

     

    You can use these HTML tags

    <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>